"katha" ,in this context, means a philosophical
debate. Sri Madhvacharya has defined 'katha' as of three types. they are
called 'vada', 'jalpa' and 'vittanda'.
Vadakatha: It is a discussion between a 'guru' and
a 'sishya' on any
philosophical topic during or after a lesson. It is
a healthy discussion intended for the benifit of the student. A student
is free to discuss with the 'guru' and even argue if he differs from him
, but has to accept the decision given by the ' guru', politeness and
respect for the teacher being observed strictly.
jalpakatha: this is a
discussion of a topic of philosopy between two
scholars of different schools of thought, or
betweeen any two persons who have divergent views. The discussion is
held with a third party as the judge on a public platform.
Srimadacharya has dealt with in detail the nature of such
discussion, selection of judges etc.
vittanda: This is a discussion
more like 'jalpa'. But when one of the
parties is losing, if he resorts
to talking without 'pramanas' or making
personal comments other party and may make comments in a rough language
the debate is called 'vittanda'.
These two works of Srimadacharya are unique in the
field of shastraic
thought.
' yO vipralambha viparItamatiprabhutAn vadAnnirasya
nikhilAn bhuvi tattvavadam sarveshvarO Haririti pratipAdayantam
Anandateertha munivaryamaham namAmi'
|