The Brahma sūtras, also known as Vedānta Sūtras,
constitute the Nyāya prasthāna, the logical starting
point of the Vedānta philosophy (Nyāya = logic/order).
No study of Vedānta is considered complete without a
close examination of the Prasthāna Traya (Prasthanatrayi),
the texts that stand as the three starting points. The
Brahma Sutras are attributed to Badarayana.
While the Upanishads (Śruti prasthāna, the starting
point of revelation) and the Bhagavad-Gītā (Smriti
prasthāna, the starting point of remembered tradition)
are the basic source texts of Vedānta, it is in the
Brahma sūtras that the teachings of Vedānta are set
forth in a systematic and logical order.
While the earlier commentators like Adi Shankara treat
Bādarāyaņa, the author of the Brahma Sūtra, as the
Jnana-Shakti Avatara (knowledge-power incarnation) of
God, Vaishnavite tradition identifies him with Krishna
Dwipayana Vyāsa, the author of the Mahābhārata.
Commentaries
Many commentaries have been written on this text, the
earliest extant one being the one by Adi Shankara. His
commentary set forth the non-dualistic (Advaita)
interpretation of the Vedānta, and was commented upon by
Vācaspati and Padmapāda. These sub-commentaries, in
turn, inspired other derivative texts in the Advaita
school.
Ramanuja also wrote a commentary on the Brahma sutra,
called Sri Bhasya, which lays the foundations of the
Vishishtadvaita tradition. In this, he firmly refutes
the Advaita view as proposed by Adi Shankara in his
commentary.
Other commentators on the Brahma Sūtras, belonging to
other schools of Vedānta, include Bhāskara,
Yādavaprakāśa, Keśava, Nīlakaņţha, Madhvacharya,
Vallabha, Vijnanabhiksu, Nimbarka, and Baladeva
Vidyābhūshaņa.
Overview
The Brahma Sūtras are also known by other names: Vedānta
Sūtras, Uttara Mīmāmsā-sūtras, Śārīraka Sūtras, Śārīraka
Mimāmsā-sūtras. Vaishnavas also call this the Bhikshu
sūtras.
The Brahma Sūtras attempt to reconcile the seemingly
contradictory and diverse statements of the various
Upanishads and the Bhagavad Gītā, by placing each
teaching in a doctrinal context. The word sūtra means
thread, and the Brahma sūtras literally stitch together
the various Vedanta teachings into a logical and
self-consistent whole.
However, the Brahma Sūtras are so terse that not only
are they capable of being interpreted in multiple ways,
but they are often incomprehensible without the aid of
the various commentaries handed down in the main schools
of Vedānta thought.
The Vedānta Sūtras supply ample evidence that at a very
early time, i.e. a period before their own final
composition, there were differences of opinion among the
various interpreters of the Vedānta. Quoted in the
Vedānta Sūtras are opinions ascribed to Audulomi,
Kārshnāgni, Kāśakŗtsna, Jaimini and Bādari, in addition
to Vyasa.
The Brahma Sūtras consist of 555 aphorisms or sūtras, in
four chapters (adhyāya), each chapter being divided into
four quarters (pāda). Each quarter consists of several
groups of sūtras called Adhikaraņas or topical sections.
An Adhikaraņa usually consists of several sūtras, but
some have only one sūtra.
The first chapter (Samanvaya: harmony) explains that all
the Vedānta texts talk of Brahman, the ultimate reality,
which is the goal of life. The very first sūtra offers
an indication into the nature of the subject matter. VS
1.1.1 athāto brahma jij?āsā - Now: therefore the inquiry
(into the real nature) of Brahman.
The second chapter (Avirodha: non-conflict) discusses
and refutes the possible objections to Vedānta
philosophy. The third chapter (Sādhana: the means)
describes the process by which ultimate emancipation can
be achieved. The fourth chapter (Phala: the fruit) talks
of the state that is achieved in final emancipation.
These sūtras systematize the j?ānakāņda (path of wisdom,
as opposed to Karmakāņda, the path of action) of the
Veda, by combining the two tasks of concisely stating
the teaching of the Veda and argumentatively
establishing the specific interpretation of the Veda
adopted in the sūtras.
The sūtras also discuss the role of karma and God and
critically address the various doctrines associated with
Buddhism, Jainism, Yoga, Nyāya, Vaisheshika, Shaiva,
Shakta, Atheism, and Sankhya philosophies.
|